NA Confidential: What they're saying ... about each other.

Friday, April 03, 2015

What they're saying ... about each other.

As the weeks go past in route to May's primary election, I'm providing periodic candidate statements of substance, mostly unretouched, as lifted from social media and news reports. Familiar gems such as "yard signs win elections, not people" and "donate to my campaign first, and maybe I'll have something of merit to say much, much later" will be omitted. That's because it is my aim to determine whether our declared candidates have anything to say at all, and I'll quote all candidates, from any and all parties, whether or not they're in a contested race. Just promising change and new ideas without divulging them won't cut the mustard, aspirants.

--

Thus far, we've tried to stay focused on the positives, and so this edition of the ongoing political survey is a departure. However, I'm prepared to argue that while the developments reported here might be viewed as "negative," each actually pertains to a differing position on a genuine topic, whether parks expansion or police bargaining. So ...

As primary election day approaches and early voting begins, races for city council in the 5th district and for mayor are getting a wee bit contentious, at least on the Democratic side.

Note that in other contested races (council 5th and 6th district Republican and Democratic council at-large), friction has yet to occur, although a Democratic at-large council candidate's comments help to frame the situation in the 5th.

Brad Bell, writing at his Fb campaign page:

The 5th District is my home district, and I am deeply concerned by Ms. (Diane) Benedetti’s comments towards Mr. (Dustin) Collins. To stoop to that level in a campaign shows that she is weak, small minded and scared that she is losing her seat. Furthermore, I feel that the hate filled nonsense coming from her campaign shows that she is no longer fit to lead our great community. In New Albany we are welcoming and hospitable toward others. She has shown neither of these qualities. She has dodged several keys votes that have come before the council, either by abstaining or not even showing up to vote. How can you call yourself a community leader when you refuse to help lead?

To be perfectly clear, no evidence has yet been submitted to corroborate widespread rumors that supporters of Benedetti have encouraged homophobia with respect to Collins, but these rumors persist, and we must assume these are the basis for Bell's social media remarks. Coincidentally or not, Collins has gotten more aggressive on social media in recent days. At his Dustin Collins for New Albany City Council page at facebook, he refers to a WDRB television news story from January 30, 2013.

Unfortunately, this post isn't an April Fools joke. My opponent actually served the City of New Albany with a lawsuit for full time benefits while serving in a part-time capacity. Throw in her votes against benefits for part-time employees and you get to see what she really thinks about the City and its employees. I'm ready to serve my constituents instead of serving my city with a lawsuit.

He also takes issue with Benedetti's park-side etiquette.

My opponent has no trouble taking credit for a successful park. She's seen here holding the ribbon for the Silver Street Park opening. There's just one problem: She voted against it. My opponent has frequently cast votes that lower the quality of life for families. We deserve someone who wants to raise the quality of life for everyone! I am that person; I want everyone to have a better New Albany.

With respect to Benedetti's participation in the lawsuit (with fellow council members Bob Caesar and Kevin Zurschmiede) and her park vote, Collins appears to be entirely factual.

In short, welcome to Politics 101: While a Democrat, Benedetti often has differed with the mayor, and candidates aligned with the mayor will be expected to take her down a notch. It's in their job descriptions, and City Hall would like nothing more than to keep the seat in the party, without her physically occupying it. Let the voting begin.

Speaking of the Democratic mayoral primary race, David White is beginning to jab. At his David White for Mayor of New Albany page at Facebook, he points to a News and Tribune article.