Tuesday, December 20, 2005

An important book on human reason and the failure of faith? Not on the bestseller list at Wally World, we can be sure.

My friend, sometimes collaborator and fellow longtime Open Air Museum curator, Joe, has come in from the gloaming after a characteristically lengthy sabbatical from the scene – and with a topical, incisive Christmas reading recommendation gleaned from C-SPAN's book talk.

It’s “The End of Faith: Religion, Terror, and the Future of Reason,” by Sam Harris.

As an enticement to run right out and purchase the book, which I almost literally did yesterday at Desperations ... er, Destinations Booksellers, Joe provided this excerpt, which can be viewed along with other snippets of text at the author’s web site:

Tell a devout Christian that his wife is cheating on him, or that frozen yogurt can make a man invisible, and he is likely to require as much evidence as anyone else, and to be persuaded only to the extent that you give it. Tell him that the book he keeps by his bed was written by an invisible deity who will punish him with fire for eternity if he fails to accept its every incredible claim about the universe, and he seems to require no evidence whatsoever.

According to reviewer Natalie Angier of the New York Times:

“The End of Faith" articulates the dangers and absurdities of organized religion so fiercely and so fearlessly that I felt relieved as I read it, vindicated, almost personally understood… Harris writes what a sizable number of us think, but few are willing to say in contemporary America … This in an important book, on a topic that, for all its inherent difficulty and divisiveness, should not be shielded from the crucible of human reason.

Perfect timing, Joe, and thanks for the tip. I'm up to page 40 already.

When I’m finished, she’s yours …

PART 2 (April – June, 2005): Why 1st District City Councilman Dan Coffey should not be selected as the council’s 2006 President.

Part 2 of 4.

NA Confidential believes that CM Dan Coffey, while indisputably eligible for the post of city council president by virtue of a measurable pulse, is fundamentally unsuited for this position of visibility and responsibility, owing to what Thomas Jefferson once referred to as a “long train of abuses and usurpations,” ones that we have assiduously documented throughout 2005.

We propose to emulate Jefferson’s method of presentation by listing these examples of unsuitability, organized quarterly and in chronological order, as we have reported them here.

The viewpoints expressed in this series are entirely ours, and all quoted passages in the series were written by The New Albanian, unless otherwise attributed.

Unfortunately, many hyperlinks to local media sources have become broken during the months since the original publication dates, and while this is infuriating from an archivist's perspective -- the Courier-Journal's inconsistent articles-for-pay policy and the Tribune's web site revamp are to blame -- it simply can’t be helped.

As always, and subject to NA Confidential's procedures, reader comments are welcomed.

April 4: UPDATED: A dynamic (hot) Air Supply reunion at Monday night's City Council meeting.

Judging from tonight's council meeting, and with a long grace period behind him, it must now be said that our 3rd District Councilman Steve Price is not only gaffe-ridden and abjectly confused. Politically, he is becoming an embarrassment to the district.

Taking Price in tandem as Tweedledee to Dan "Wizard of Westside" Coffey's Tweededum, or as Charlie McCarthy or Mortimer Snerd to Coffey's Edgar Bergen -- and given the sad propensity of both Price and Coffey to admire the dulcet tones of their own voices for periods of time far longer than that required for Hannibal to march elephants over the Alps -- I am quite frankly apologetic for ever having castigated Mayor James Garner for his periodic difficulties in communicating.

It would seem that Mayor Garner at least knows when not to speak, and that even if his words aren't always ideal, he at least knows the material.

Price can lay claim to neither of these virtues, and to make his performance even more unfortunate, he refrains from butchering the syntax only when Coffey pauses to take a drink of water.

Tonight's dispiriting performance by a self-aggrandizing ward heeler obsessed with locked public park toilets (Coffey), and his fawning 3rd District acolyte Price ("we won't get no riverboat money") serves to remind us of how far we must travel before genuine change takes root and grows.

April 5: Campaign slogans we'd like to see.

Coffey for Mayor in '07: "You trusted him with the keys to the public toilet … now trust him with the keys to the city.”

April 17: The time is now for New Albany's Constituency for Progress.

Decades pass. Our worthiest sons and daughters – the bright, capable and eager future leaders of the city – get away from New Albany as fast as they can, far away from institutionalized slum lord debasement not just tolerated but welcomed over a period of four or more decades, away from the overcrowded and trashy Harvest Homecoming that is our sole and only claim to infamy, away from a place where any good idea, any sign of intelligent life, any revolt against the lumpy mashed potato norm is dismissed and derided as craziness emanating from a book-reading, un-American faggot who can just move the hell out if he or she doesn't like it here ...

... Remember, we’re looking for something that can be achieved empirically at a fundamental level of everyday life throughout the city, something that can be measured and quantified, and something that can unite those of like mind.

And, punish those opposed. If this elusive “something” also costs our current crop of politicians votes, then that’s even better.

April 18: City Councilman Cappuccino speaks with NA Confidential.

NAC: The rule of law?

CC: (Exasperated) Law, schmaw. No, VOTES! Can’t live with ‘em when they’re cast by those hoity toity East Enders, and can’t live without ‘em if they’re my neighbors on the West Side! They don’t call me the Wizard for nothing, you know. At the same time, my world-famous barbecued bologna cookouts only go so far, and at some point, you have to earn the respect of your constituents, and one great way to do that is to protect them from the heat.

NAC: Mr. Cappuccino, what were your thoughts last year when the city of New Albany began enforcing the right of way for street sweeping?

DC: Quite frankly, it was a blatant attack on our cherished West End way of life – family, church, iced tea, NASCAR and the ice cream social, all under siege by the Silver Hills elite and the book-readin’ snobs. You know, I’d call it discrimination, maybe even genocide … if I knew what genocide meant …

April 22: This just in: Council's Coffey announces Anschluss with city's 3rd District, appoints Price as property manager, announces "drainage in our time"

Abruptly at 8:02 p.m., Coffey jauntily announced his contempt for the principles of teamwork, piously intoning that he hadn’t bothered attending Tuesday’s city budget work session because unidentified officials refuse to let him have “all the pieces to the puzzle.”

Not that he wouldn’t find them on his own, mind you, and of course he will manage to do so, against all the odds …

... You could almost hear the public toilet keys jangling in Coffey’s pocket.

As is customary, Coffey’s bravura performance satisfied all the requirements of his favored brand of reactionary retro chic: Ward heeler, demagogue, and populist savior of the downtrodden suffering at the hands of the (fill in the blank) conspiracy.

Coffey’s council persona is calculated to baffle and intimidate his less experienced legislative brethren, and to play to the folks in Coffey’s home district, who after all is said and done must remain somehow “oppressed” if the Wizard is to retain a viable political pulse.

However, as was convincingly demonstrated in the recent Democratic leadership contest when his bid for party secretary was crushed, Coffey’s citywide appeal is considerably less universal than the adoration within his fiefdom.

Unfortunately for Coffey, this situation is a serious impediment to the aspirations of a small-time neighborhood politico who craves power not because he is capable of offering the slightest glimpse as to the future direction of the city of New Albany, or can truly grasp the Freudian nature of recurring drainage obsessions, but because he seeks to perpetuate each and every discredited local stereotype by sticking it to the uppity book readers, the snotty degree holders, the pie-in-the-sky progressives, and most importantly, those people from all walks of life who are too preoccupied with their lives to pay sufficient attention to the political theater that is Dan Coffey.

Accordingly, to wreak his preferred style of self-aggrandizing havoc outside the boundaries of the 1st District, Coffey needs strategic allies on the council. And, in the time-honored fashion, such allies need not agree on every individual point just so long as they unite on shared central issues, which in the case of the current City Council is that espoused by the faction inhabited by Coffey, which opposes virtually every activity undertaken by City Hall and the person of Mayor James Garner.

May 1: "No progress at any price" faction may use New Albany's budget crisis as an excuse to target Scribner Place.

Specifically, in her article, the ‘Bune’s Lowry notes that “council member Dan Coffey suggests that the Scribner Place project be put on hold.”

The city’s contribution to the Scribner Place project is coming in the form of land acquisition, preparation and infrastructure, and this is the money (for this year and next) referred to by Councilman Coffey.

Wear knee-high boots if you have them, because Coffey’s linking of the budget crisis with Scribner Place is an obvious signal that potentially divisive public grandstanding is about to occur.

As the perpetual ward-heeling politico who lacks vision the way that albino mice lack pigment, Coffey probably intends to glad-hand the city’s depressingly morose “no progress at any price” faction by arguing that the city’s budget cuts provide “proof” that thinking in the future tense is mistaken.

May 2: UPDATED: Open thread: What did you think of the City Council's performance tonight?

What was the single most annoying moment of the evening?

Mine would have to be Councilman Cappuccino ... er, Coffey's response to the statement of Greg Roberts, who had praised Councilman Donnie Blevins for being of service during Saturday's Clean Up New Albany work day.

Coffey felt compelled to point out that his fawning acolyte, Steve Price, had been out there working along with all the others, and had in fact paid out of his own pocket for people to help clean the streets ... and, to Coffey, Price's dispensing of cash was more impressive than someone (i.e., Blevins) who was on the clock in his role as sanitation department superintendent.

As Coffey proved that he is far more than a demagogue (he's a playground bully, too), and Price made sounds like a lowing calf, we were reminded of the early M*A*S*H episodes, when Margaret Houlihan would defend Frank Burns while the camp rolled its collective eyes.

May 3: Fly on the wall, gnat in "Comments": NAC listens as Citizen Huckleberry slurs Southern Indiana United Soccer Club.

Citizen Huckleberry speaks for that segment of New Albany’s population that considers themselves to be besieged on all sides by strange outsiders who want to make the city a better place to live, work, and raise children … and, recoiling from the prospect of a well-adjusted and productive social order, they chant the words of the Grinch with a certain nostalgic fondness:

“I must stop this whole thing! Why, for fifty-three years I've put up with it now. I must stop (it) from coming ... but how?

He has a perfect right to continue speaking, and he no doubt will do so irrespective of NA Confidential’s or anyone else’s opinion on the matter, but it is important for those of us who believe in the power of ideas and the possibilities afforded by an intelligent future to understand that not all of our brethren agree, and they -- like Citizen Huckleberry, Councilman Cappuccino and Li’l Stevie, they are prepared to fight ... to obstruct progress.

May 4: An evening on the brink: Tragicomic opera courtesy of NA's Siamese councilmen.

Q: Mr. Cappuccino, how many audits will be needed before you can remember what you missed during your previous term on the council?

A: Why, it's obvious, son - cut Scribner Place!

1st District councilman Dan Coffey plays the game of ward politics like Liberace played the grand piano, with a costumed, grandiloquent bravado so transparently obvious as to submerge any notion of subtlety or restraint beneath a positively Nixonian tsunami of rampant insecurity and malignant overcompensation.

If you were to encounter a piranha on the street, and the carnivorous fish proffers his fin and tells you he’s given up meat for Lent, the ensuing skepticism necessary to protect you against losing a digit or two would be no match for the wave of audible chortling that filled the third-floor meeting room of the City-County building Monday evening when Coffey again skillfully evaded even the remotest sense of irony and kept a straight, if reddened, face while denying any interest in “playing politics” during a heated discussion over Mayor James Garner’s general fund repair plan.

If Coffey could somehow muster just a fraction of Liberace’s deft touch at high camp, the incident might be laughed off as a harmlessly small-town politico objecting to the sun’s habit of rising in the East, but unfortunately a steady diet of barbecued bologna has been known to starve the body of the vitamins it needs to behave responsibly at times of crisis, and so the Wizard of Westside continues to hector, bloviate, bully and grandstand in opposition to a resolution of the city’s budget crisis.

Although, not to the extent of casting an unequivocal “no” vote during the first reading of two separate parts of Mayor James Garner’s plan. An entire evening’s worth of unrelenting demagoguery produced the stunningly sparse yield of two abstentions by Coffey, the second of which was so damningly indicative of Coffey’s craven abdication of responsibility that even Steve Price of the “District Formerly Known as the Third, and Now Identified by a Symbol from a Captain Marvel Comic Book that Stands for First and a Half” resisted the tug on his leash and voted “yes.”

To find the best contemporary example of Coffey’s careful grooming of Price into an obsequious, fawning sycophant, you’d have to travel to Pyongyang and view the posters that proclaim Kim Jong Il as the fountain of all human knowledge.

Like Price, captive North Koreans know when to stand up, sit down and roll over, and these talents are helpful when one is faced with the prospect of his revered leader (Coffey, not Mr. Kim) droning for hours on selected matters that range from proper drainage and the untrustworthiness of professional engineering to newspaper proofreading and an unmatched record of attendance at public works board meetings.

May 9: The Coffey/Price dumbumvirate's rear-guard action against progress.

A City Council faction has developed, led by the forever erratic and increasingly malevolent Dan Coffey (1st District), pneumatically seconded by the pliant Coffey sycophant Steve Price (3rd District), and frequently but not always abetted by at least two veteran councilmen who apparently have yet to grasp the mean-spirited medievalism that courses through Coffey’s veins like incendiary fuel through a flamethrower that is aimed squarely at a village soon to be destroyed in order to be “saved.”

The Coffey/Price dumbumvirate is taking the city to the edge of the abyss, not just to discredit the current occupant of the mayor’s chair, which is a given, but also to wage what plainly amounts to crass cultural warfare against those citizens of New Albany who are best placed to assist in boosting the city’s hopes of getting smarter to get better, even as state, national and world economies show no signs of waiting for us to rub two sticks together, make a fire, and begin barbecuing our council Wizard’s bologna.

The dumbumvirate’s alternative plan is to unilaterally suspend the city’s project of constructing infrastructure for the Scribner Place downtown development, and to divert money from Scribner Place as a means of balancing the budget.

It remains unclear whether the money in question can indeed be diverted, but this vital consideration should not detract from a clear understanding of what our Siamese councilmen are most interested in achieving, which is a rear-guard action against progress in any and all forms, a crusade borne of obvious spite, simple envy, and the type of sneer you’d expect to see on the face of a playground bully, not an elected official.

May 16: Politics, preservation and a festival -- or, the week ahead in New Albany.

It’s 3rd District Councilman Steve Price, who will be attending this meeting only two days before he casts votes critical to the city’s future … but will his “handler” dare to permit Price to comment on an increasingly regressive voting record and the fumbling public advocacy of positions that aren’t favored within the 3rd District?

Verily, only The Cappuccino knows for sure.

Word on the street is that Price’s politically conjoined benefactor, 1st District Councilman Dan Coffey, fears the messy outcome of an unscripted meeting between Price and his constituents.

Recognizing that Edgar Bergen remains dead and thus is unavailable for the job, Coffey plans to attend the meeting, presumably intent on performing selected arias from the “Bloviate’s Shuffle” while protecting his acolyte, Price, from well-deserved scrutiny.

May 18: Price rocks S. Ellen Jones: The last person to leave New Albany, please douse the candles and drop off your keys at the Brambleberry residence.

(Minus Coffey) 3rd District Councilman Steve Price was capably supported by the hard-riffing “Fact” Masters, his backing band, whose morose recitation of impenetrable and unverifiable rhythmic cadences freed the headlining Price to explore countless creative variations on a solitary, numbingly repetitive melody from his chart-topping single, “Paralysis.”

May 27: UPDATED: Scribner Place: Who's for it, who's against it, and who hasn't decided.

(Louis) Schmitt, by all accounts a successful and respected local businessman, obviously is a proponent of the Scribner Place/YMCA project.

This fact would be entirely unremarkable if not for the incessant hue and cry from the city’s blinkered flat-earthers, grandstanding Brambleberries, petty obstructionists and unrepentant Luddites, who demand variously that the city of New Albany operate according to the dictates of their own admittedly threadbare household finances, but beyond even that, from the trustworthy perspective of good business practices.

June 3: "Cave living is the life for me," notes CM Cappuccino as City Council work session considers city's role in YMCA, Scribner Place.

(Reported by Rick Carmickle).

CM Coffey directed this comment to Mr. LaRocca.

-- This city is in a crisis as far as budget and funding, so why doesn’t the YMCA take over the whole project, and eliminate the middleman, the city. With the city not involved, your project will speed up and become a reality much sooner. The money funded by Caesars is there -- ask them for all of it up front, use that $10 million, and only have to borrow $5 million, instead of putting this city into further debt.

Mayor Garner interjected that the city still owns the land and leases it to the YMCA for a one dollar a year.

Mr. Ricke and Mr. LaRocca stated that since the beginning, this project has been a three-way joint effort with the City of New Albany, YMCA and Caesars Foundation, and that they could not speak for the other two parties, but would take it under advisement.

June 5: City Hall admits to hiding Scribner Place information under the bedroom mattress, along with swimsuit issue and a spare key to the safe.

Speaking of the perpetual quest for information on the part of certain City Council members, who echo Bono's oft-stated view that he still hasn't found what he's looking for, the following is an unexpectedly informative comment thread from Speak Out Loud NA, which heretofore has served primarily to “empower” the voiceless outrage of generally anonymous citizens (who’ve donned a variety of masks and taken assorted guises, many emanating in spluttering clusters of semi-legible comments posted in the early morning hours, and probably from the same IP address).

Whiskey River, take my mind ...

June 7: Monday night's City Council meeting: “24 eyeballs are better than 4 or 6,” but only if they’re properly cooked.

The meeting wasn’t always smooth, and it was not without an occasional glitch -- it simply wouldn’t seem right if Councilman Dan Coffey didn’t throw a red-faced tantrum by evening’s end, and this he duly contributed over the unexpected topic of the patio home development at State Street and Kenzig Road -- but all in all, our elected officials toned down the rhetoric and went about their tasks with determination.

At the same time, there can be no doubt that the 2007 election season has started in earnest, with much of what was said and done on Monday capable of being interpreted by means of the hoary “local politics” playbook.

June 12: The Tribune's Amany Ali fearlessly shines a light into the dark corridors of troglodyte misinformation.

But star billing this Sunday must be given to the Tribune’s city editor, Amany Ali, whose column, “New Albany has its share of problems,” is an ambitious effort to focus attention on the persistent, destructive presence of a cult of misinformation in New Albany.

Her writing is mature, her anecdotes amusing, and her stylish denunciation of the roots of misinformation unstinting. The Tribune has performed a valuable public service in publishing this illumination of the devious methodology favored by the community’s “no progress at any price” obstructionists.

June 16: City council tonight, but first, a few words about the nature of progress.

Receptivity to new ideas and new methods is a central facet of a progressive worldview, and when applied toward the imperative of improving the quality of life in New Albany, such an attitude of openness must characterize our economic development strategies as well as the view we hold of ourselves as members of a community and possessors both of rights and responsibilities.

At this crucial juncture in the history of New Albany, we see elements of a progressive ideal struggle to take root and grow. These efforts are manifested by the actions of citizens both within and outside of governing circles, ranging from small businessmen downtown to the members of neighborhood associations, and from earnest bids to advance the cause of historical preservation to worthwhile and justifiable governmental projects to provide impetus to revitalization.

June 17: Coffey to Redevelopment Commission: I'm clueless, and you should be, too.

For the record, Dan Coffey represents the 1st council district, which arguably stands to benefit the most from both Scribner Place and any future redevelopment in the project's immediate vicinity.

Meanwhile, the market that currently exists for "such private development" extends well into the 3rd District, represented by Steve Price, who also is opposed to the Scribner Place project. Naturally, the potential market ranges far beyond the blade-thin perspectives of Coffey and Price, who seem to be echoing the traditional New Albany refrain of "we can't."

June 17: Price to citizenry: I'm scared, and you should be, too.

We’ll leave the Pavlovian implications of (Steve) Price’s jerking knee and ticklish larynx to those trained in the fields of psychology, sociology and Wal-Mart shopping.

Credit my unrepresentative representative for having completed a difficult mid-term transition, from clinging Coffeyite toady to cynically calculating practitioner of the political art of the scare tactic, which is designed to arouse groundless fears in the minds of voters, and then to cite these fears as evidence of the claim he is making.

Accordingly, New Albany’s “no progress at any Price” sect is happy to have Li’l Stevie as its council spokesman. Although council allies of the unreconstructed Brambleberries, apart from Price, remain on board the Luddite bandwagon, their public rhetoric has become increasingly muted, leaving him as the Ken doll rallying point for the retrograde movement to 1948.

June 21: Rog's rant: On the very nature of nay-saying.

Why must we perpetually insist that superstition and backwardness are our best friends?

I’m not speaking here about Scribner Place, Cannon Acres, the City Council, the Mayor, or any of the specific local political topics that have been discussed at NA Confidential since its inception last year.

Rather, with the memory of Chicago’s vibrant neighborhoods and can-do spirit fresh in my mind, I’m referring to the recurring phenomenon hereabouts that currently enjoys its most prominent, and saddest, manifestation in apoplectic opposition to progress in the city of New Albany, an opposition that unfortunately doesn’t confine itself to screaming that present circumstances stand in the way of progress, but that taken together, all past mistakes by any and all politicians and community leaders indicate that we simply can’t do anything right, and should never, ever try.

I am utterly sickened by this cancerous attitude.

June 22: Two classics at Volunteer Hoosier are required reading in progressive New Albania.

“Coffey Brake, or, If I Could Save Time in a Bottle," By Randy Smith, Volunteer Hoosier.

"I'm here to tell Mr. (Dan) Coffey, quality of life doesn't just happen. As an elected official, it is his responsibility to use the resources of this community to build. It is not his prerogative to sit on his ass and rely on "someone else" to do it. He must be accountable to the second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth, and seventh generations.”

June 23: Councilman Cappuccino declares city administration null and void, invites YMCA to form provisional government with himself as regent.

The development proposal that so plagued Cappuccino surely was missing its single most important ingredient, the key fundamental element, the one crucial aspect without which there could be no hope for his approval, no chance for the project’s ultimate success, and no progress at any price.

Why, Cappuccino himself.

The councilman’s indelible stamp was nowhere to be found. Neither had he giddily appeared on television, nor had the public seen his stern and statesmanlike visage displayed in the local newspapers.

Kept infernally busy interfering daily with affairs in council districts other than his own, Cappuccino had thus far played a negligible role as the development project was debated and inched forward, and now, with the clock ticking, how could he yet manage to claim credit for moving the project forward – or, as the case may be, for tossing the decisive spanner into the works to have the project stopped or altered, thus discrediting his major political enemy?

June 28: UPDATED: Councilman Dan Coffey on Scribner Place: “It’s gonna happen. It has to happen.”

Just as the sum of a half dozen zeroes is still zero, so the impact of the Coffey Plan, as presented by the councilman to an audience precluded by accepted protocol from speaking, and illustrated with poster board, magic marker and hastily assembled snapshots of dilapidated houses and potholed streets, was no more than that of a balefully muted fart at a rock and roll show.

June 29: More work session thoughts from Tuesday night, June 28.

To the vast majority of human observers, the world is a dauntingly complex place. Fortunately, New Albany has 1st District Councilman Coffey to publicly elucidate the principles of benign simplicity.

Thus, while many of us look to towns of similar size and history like Columbus and Madison to serve as models for progress, the Wizard of Westside sets his gaze on simpler and better examples of cleanliness and organization.

“New Albany can be like Birdseye,” he said last evening, as an astonished crowd listened and asked, just exactly where is Birdseye?

And why would a council member compare Birdseye to a city of 40,000 residents?

Monday, December 19, 2005

PART 1 (January – March, 2005): Why 1st District City Councilman Dan Coffey should not be selected as the council’s 2006 President.

Part 1 of 4.

NA Confidential believes that CM Dan Coffey, while indisputably eligible for the post of city council president by virtue of a measurable pulse, is fundamentally unsuited for this position of visibility and responsibility, owing to what Thomas Jefferson once referred to as a “long train of abuses and usurpations,” ones that we have assiduously documented throughout 2005.

We propose to emulate Jefferson’s method of presentation by listing these examples of unsuitability, organized quarterly and in chronological order, as we have reported them here.

The viewpoints expressed in this series are entirely ours, and all quoted passages in the series were written by The New Albanian, unless otherwise attributed.

Unfortunately, many hyperlinks to local media sources have become broken during the months since the original publication dates, and while this is infuriating from an archivist's perspective -- the Courier-Journal's inconsistent articles-for-pay policy and the Tribune's web site revamp are to blame -- it simply can’t be helped.

As always, and subject to NA Confidential's procedures, reader comments are welcomed.

January 24: NA Confidential challenges both the Mayor and the City Council to improve communications with the people of this city.

At last week’s City Council meeting, a citizen speaker asked how many of the eight council members present for duty (Bill Schmidt was ill) had visited the city’s web site lately.

One member raised his hand. There was a half-hearted nod from another. Some looked down at the floor, while others eyed the ceiling. Dan Coffey stated publicly that he hadn’t looked at the web site for a couple of years. All members present looked uncomfortable at having been put on the spot.

January 28: Blevins, Laduke and Toran appear before the East Spring Street Neighborhood Association.

Furthermore, it was pointedly noted that concerns relayed by citizens to their elected council representatives also should be presented before the BPWS. To illustrate this point, Steve produced complete minutes from 2004 BPWS meetings that showed which council members had taken constituent problems to the board.

According to the minutes, only Bill Schmidt (numerous times), Larry Kochert and Donnie Blevins did so in 2004.

The message was clear, to the point, and buttressed by the presence of Donnie, who agreed that City Council members may or may not know correct procedures, and may or may not play by the rules when they do, for what might be political reasons – or, as Steve answered when asked by an audience member, for the sake of "power."

February 8: NA Confidential vs. NA Incontinent at Monday's City Council meeting.

Dan Coffey’s immediate, visceral and jarringly defensive reaction was as indicative of an ill-tempered, anti-progressive mindset as one is apt to find without running to the library for transcripts of Senator McCarthy’s 1950’s-era witch hunt hearings in the US Senate.

These hearings might be available on video for the benefit of those who feel threatened by the act of reading.

Coincidentally, Dan Coffey does not read Blogs because “anyone can hide behind the keyboard,” but by means of osmosis or the Vulcan mind meld, he purports to know exactly what is written in NA Confidential.

Dan Coffey, who sits as part of an elected body known as the “city” council, which is charged with matters pertaining to the city as a whole, sees no need to speak with anyone outside his own district, where he holds public meetings six times a year ... and ... hey, you ... outsider … you don’t live here, do you? … well, congratulations, you’ve just been invited not to attend!

Dan Coffey emphatically and abrasively possesses not the slightest intention to attend any town hall, public forum or revival meeting that is not organized by himself in the safety of his own fiefdom, especially if he’s invited only to listen to the taxpayers throughout the city who pay his salary (and whose money he spends) rather than speak himself.

February 18: “Steve, sometimes we have to listen to what’s going on.”

(Quote from Councilman Dan Coffey, who after three almost uninterrupted hours of listening to himself speak paused long enough to urge colleague Steve Price to do the same).

February 18: City Council seeks "leadership" transplant; donors scarce in New Albany.

Dan Coffey uses most of each meeting to prattle, pontificate and insert himself into every conceivable nook and cranny that might someday come in handy to further the pursuance of his partisan political agenda, whatever it is.

The same tired attack dogs are trotted out, meeting after meeting. Like some Pavlovian experiment gone haywire, the same stimuli prompt the same responses, meeting after meeting. Observers can predict almost to the second when the imaginary red light flashes, the salivary glands take their cue, and one or the other council member launches into their time-tested grandstanding routines.

February 20: If Muzak is playing but there's no one around to hear it ...

A StoneDeaf Band reunion at a benefit concert at the Trinkle Dome, and accompanying anti-porno telethon, with speaking slots for the Mullah Goebel and Councilman Dan “Wizard of Westside” Coffey … plenty of lemonade, weenies and elephant ears, and all proceeds going to buy a couple gallons of gasoline and a Bic to help send the evil pornographers packing.

Then, concerned citizen David Huckleberry could use the leftover flammables to roust the remaining bars and taverns downtown ... and we would be free to descend into a golden era of conformity, sterility and Third World taxation rates.

February 23: Floyd County Demos seek new leader.

Although Randy (Stumler) may have disqualified himself for a party leadership role by daring to express a progressive vision for the city of New Albany, and at half Nash’s age would undoubtedly frighten the stodgier party pillars, the thought of a bona fide teacher manning the controls of Floyd County’s Democrats is a pleasant one.

Consider the indigestion it likely would induce in Dan “Wizard of Westside” Coffey’s Anti-Thought Gang. That alone would be worth the price of admission.

February 24: On disappointment, epiphanies and progress.

All too often our political luminaries inform us that progress is bad, and stagnation is good – it’s preserving our way of life, we’re told – except that in the absence of movement forward, there is no standing still because the only constant is change, so instead, there is regress, and regress is the lifeblood of the populist political cadre that has dominated New Albany for decades, content to obfuscate progressive attitudes and impede the efforts of progressives because the atmosphere engendered by progress is incompatible with the retention of control by the traditional system.

After all, nothing scares the big fish in the little pond more than the pond becoming bigger.

Progressive or regressive?

Yesterday we considered the forthcoming Democratic Party leadership contest. A slate was provided. On one side are names like Randy Stumler, Marcey Wisman and Tony Toran.

On the other, one name stands out: Dan Coffey.

February 28: Although we can't spell "obscenity," we sure as hell know it when we see it ... by the way, is that item for sale?

Citizen Coffey is to be commended for belatedly swapping his elected persona for a more properly expressed private one, which places him firmly within the ranks of concerned taxpayers like David Huckleberry, whose recent suggestion that we do a better job of fleecing Caesar’s-bound motorists drew enthusiastic nods from Councilman Coffey.

However, Coffey is heartbroken at the sight of New Albany DVD, a rare “new business” that even the Wizard can see fits the bill of enticing transitory Louisvillians to spend money in New Albany, something that “local residents” assuredly won’t do … but these same “local residents” still must pay, either by pledging the money they wouldn’t spend on adult DVDs toward a crusade to uproot the store, or providing it indirectly to city government to atone for its botched campaign against the First Amendment.

All the while, whether through Coffey’s congenital grandstanding or the city’s mangled legal strategies, New Albany DVD is provided free publicity and maximum exposure (pun intended) far beyond what it could receive in paid advertising.

March 7: Weekend political recap: Floyd Demos, GOP select new leaders.

Over the past weekend, both of Floyd County’s mainstream political parties met to select new leadership.

Coming later today: Why 1st District Councilman Dan Coffey should not be selected as the city council’s 2006 president (Part 1 of 4).

Yesterday, in Luddites seek to restrict franchise to anonymous blog posters in prelude to wee junta, NA Confidential wrote:

NA Confidential believes that CM (Donnie) Blevins is as good a choice as any sitting council member for the presidency, and that he is a better choice than CM (Dan) Coffey, who while not the worst imaginable prospect (see “3rd council district, shame of”), is philosophically and temperamentally unsuited to preserve order, to preserve decorum, and to act as the city council’s face to the public for the coming year, a year in which the city of New Albany will begin substantive building upon its hard-earned progress of the months past.

Beginning later tonight with the first installment, NA Confidential will devote Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday to the presentation of a four-part series dedicated to the proposition that 1st District Councilman Dan Coffey absolutely should not under any circumstances be selected as the New Albany City Council’s president for the year 2006.

NA Confidential believes that CM Coffey, while indisputably eligible for the post of city council president by virtue of a measurable pulse, is fundamentally unsuited for this position of visibility and responsibility, owing to what Thomas Jefferson once referred to as a “long train of abuses and usurpations,” ones that we have assiduously documented throughout 2005.

We propose to emulate Jefferson’s method of presentation by listing these examples of unsuitability, organized quarterly and in chronological order, as we have reported them here.

The viewpoints expressed in this series are entirely ours, and all quoted passages in the series were written by The New Albanian, unless otherwise attributed.

Unfortunately, many hyperlinks to local media sources have become broken during the months since the original publication dates, and while this is infuriating from an archivist's perspective -- the Courier-Journal's inconsistent articles-for-pay policy and the Tribune's web site revamp are to blame -- it simply can’t be helped.

As always, and subject to NA Confidential's procedures, reader comments are welcomed.

Sunday, December 18, 2005

Luddites seek to restrict franchise to anonymous blog posters in prelude to wee junta.

It’s hardly surprising that for some, a new year’s “new beginning” is little more than a hasty regurgitation of the same agenda-laden agitprop of their previous twelve defeat-plagued months, which naturally brings to mind the familiar definition of insanity:

Doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.

Which brings us, suitably kicking and screaming like sleep-deprived banshees, to the next item on the New Albany political calendar: The City Council’s selection of a President, which is slated for the body’s first 2006 meeting on Monday, January 9 (note the meeting date change).

What’s at stake? According to New Albany’s code of ordinances:

TITLE III: ADMINISTRATION
CHAPTER 30: COMMON COUNCIL
30.16 PRESIDENT.

(A) The President shall preside at all meetings, preserve order, decorum and decide all questions of order subject to appeal to the Common Council. He shall appoint all standing committees and all special committees that may be ordered by the Council. All standing committees shall be appointed at the commencement of each year of the term of Council and shall serve only during the term of the President appointing same. He shall fill all existing vacancies that may thereafter occur in any of such committees.

(B) He shall sign all ordinances, orders and resolutions passed by the Council before their presentation to the Mayor, as well as the journal of proceedings.

(C) He shall vote on all issues, his name being called last.

('71 Code, §30.05) (Ord. 4600, passed 3-4-57)

There seems to be nothing explicitly written herein suggesting heroic presidential powers to call for audits, investigations and carryout Chinese from Hing Wang, but maybe we’re not reading closely enough between the lines.

Already the political odds makers are surveying the tea leaves, casting the leadership contest as a fight between at-large CM Donnie Blevins and the Wizard of Westside, 1st District CM Dan Coffey, and foreseeing a 4-4 split with the lone Republican councilman, Mark Seabrook, holding the kingmaker’s deciding vote.

Down at the Luddite Bar & Grill, Coffey has received early support from the sparse and motley crowd of choleric naysayers, squelch-blooded obstructionists and hooded libel-peddlers who devote hours of meandering blog karaoke to the pronouncements of the Trog Sham(an), who provides this somewhat less than inspiring endorsement for CM Coffey:

He may be brash, and he may indeed be guilty of a bit of grandstanding at times, but I would still rather put the the next year of this faltering City in the hands of a bold personality than I would those of a meek and unknowledgeable newcomer, just because he is NOT Dan Coffey …

… Don't get me wrong folks, I am not a Dan Coffey "fan", and we have had our share of differences along the way. However, I am willing to put aside those differences, and step back to look at what the City needs as a whole. This isn't about personality conflicts, this is business.

For Trog Sham to prefer the “boldness” of CM Coffey, an underachieving council veteran, to the “meek and unknowledgeable newcomer,” CM Blevins, is perfectly acceptable as a matter of opinion, but it is highly disingenuous for her to piously insist that this preference does not derive from “personality conflicts.”

Given the tortured worldview of the unhappy crowd at the Luddite, it’s not just a personality conflict that is being expressed by open contempt for CM Blevins – it’s the very ultimate in personality conflicts.

For those who remain wedded to the immobile, demeaning and futile doctrine of fixed social class, CM Blevins has committed the unpardonable sin of failing to fall on his sword for the sake of his brethren, i.e., the soon-to-disappear sanitation department.

It is an intense, vitriolic and deeply personal conflict, and should be viewed accordingly sans insincere whitewash.

But … always dimly aware that some semblance of intellectual legitimacy must be contrived to hurriedly veil such naked, undisguised acrimony so as to provide a purely expedient but sloppy patina of respectability, Trog Sham’s advocacy of CM Coffey – to her, the anti-Blevins – leads to the bizarre argument that people like CM Blevins shouldn’t allowed in a council seat in the first place:

… City employees sitting as general Council Members are practically inviting trouble, as their employment with the City will certainly carry some weight in their decision making and voting on matters that directly, or indiretly, impact the departments they are associated with. Already, we've witnessed complications that arose from City employee and Council Member, Donnie Blevins …

Even Jack Messer, as a City Police Officer, is straddling the fence by holding a seat on the Council, because he is percieved as having too much influence in too many arenas of City business. This caused great concern when he was considered for the position of Code Enforcement Officer, and eventually led to a great deal of anomosity as tempers flared on both sides of the issue …

… I ask you, does Jack Messer really even belong on the Council, as a matter of principle?

Breathtakingly, Trog Sham drags CM Messer back into the line of fire while positing that it is a logical impossibility for a city employee – or more accurately, a city employee who disagrees with her -- to serve as an elected official without an unavoidable, intolerable, built-in conflict of interest, and thus she proposes to erect yet another barrier to civic participation in her ideal troglodyte encampment.

This morning, on his blog, former councilman Maury Goldberg asks:

No employees of the City of New Albany should be President of the New Albany City Council? Ok. Should Floyd County Council President Ted Hearvin, an employee of the Floyd County Sheriff Department, quit as its president? Or let’s pose the question: Should a governmental employee be allowed to hold an elective office?

Taking Trig Sham’s ill-considered disenfranchisement plea to its logical conclusion would result in barring numerous citizens from elected office, because in addition to incumbents like Heavrin, Messer and Blevins, there are other unsuitable elements lurking within the halls of the City-County Building, aren’t there?

CM Seabrook operates a business – will he seek to manipulate council business to improve the prospects for his own?

CM Bev Crump sells real estate – are we saying that she can’t be trusted to exercise judgment on zoning issues?

CM Steve Price owns rental property – surely we can’t expect him to remain impartial on issues impacting his investment?

Here is an excerpt from the FAQ at the Robert’s Rules of Order web site:

Under the rules in RONR, no member can be compelled to refrain from voting simply because it is perceived that he or she may have some "conflict of interest" with respect to the motion under consideration. If a member has a direct personal or pecuniary (monetary) interest in a motion under consideration not common to other members, the rule in RONR is that he should not vote on such a motion, but even then he or she cannot be compelled to refrain from voting. [RONR (10th ed.), p. 394, l. 15-25.]

The mere possibility of a council member failing to exercise proper discretion in a case of “direct personal or pecuniary (monetary) interest” does not provide sufficient grounds for seeking to ban an entire segment of the city’s population from public service.

In fact, applying this ludicrous “no city employee” standard to the question of public service inevitably leads to an equally ludicrous conclusion, holding that because virtually any responsive individual in the community who works toward its betterment shares a conflict of interest in the broader sense that community improvement benefits each and every resident, including himself or herself, then only those with no interest at all in community improvement can be relied upon to properly serve the community.

Huh? How many Brambleberries can we expect to find?

Given that in the past months, Trog Sham’s supporters have advanced variously loony ideas that if taken literally would preclude newcomers, non-property owners, non-Christians and book readers from taking part in the local civic dialogue, those whiffs of fascistic intolerance we’re smelling are becoming increasingly odious – and more pathetically desperate – with each passing day.

In fact, each current sitting city council member is qualified to serve on the council, having met eligibility standards and having been elected by voters who are perfectly free to repudiate their choices in the forthcoming 2007 contest.

In fact, and furthermore, each currently sitting city council member is qualified, according to the rules of the game, to serve as President of the council during 2006.

NA Confidential believes that CM Blevins is as good a choice as any sitting council member for the presidency, and that he is a better choice than CM Coffey, who while not the worst imaginable prospect (see “3rd council district, shame of”), is philosophically and temperamentally unsuited to preserve order, to preserve decorum, and to act as the city council’s face to the public for the coming year, a year in which the city of New Albany will begin substantive building upon its hard-earned progress of the months past.

For now, we’ll leave it at that.

Okay, so it took a while for the Tribune to see it ...

In Saturday’s Tribune, the newspaper’s anonymous composer of headlines offers a classically understated take on the obvious:

Garner, council members differ on progress; Communication seems to be a problem area, by Chris Morris (News-Tribune).

Morris quotes CM Mark Seabrook:

“I have been on three councils, and I have never seen such hostility toward the mayor, and council members against other council members,” he said. “I’ve never seen it like this before. There is a tremendous communication gap between everybody.”

And, CM Seabrook again:

“We spend too much time talking about the past instead of dealing with the future and reality.”

Why, yes.

Surveying the ranks of New Albany’s public officials at all levels, CM Seabrook’s comment is telling.

The questions we all need to be asking are, “where are the reality-based ideas for dealing with the future?” and “how do we begin bringing them to fruition?”

NA Confidential submits that the answers are being provided on the ground, in the community, and bubbling up from the grassroots – sometimes above, and often below, the ineffectual radar of traditional media and our cadre of backward thinking public officials as exemplified by the council’s Gang of Four.

We expect the contrasts between achievement and obstructionism to be even more vivid come 2007 and the next election cycle ... and we can’t wait to be proven right.

----

In the Sunday edition of the Tribune, there is letter to the editor from Board of Public Works and Safety member Steve LaDuke, in which Steve meticulously dispels the Internet-engendered and politically motivated mistruths and rumors surrounding last week's sanitation bids. If a link to the letter comes available, it will be provided in this space.

Saturday, December 17, 2005

Whistling while you work toward progress.

Elsewhere I’ve posted a Saturnalia opening night recap of sorts. Check it out if you’re interested. The brewery’s now back to brewing, and maybe I can settle down to enjoy the season.

When my night crew reported for duty last evening at five, I continued to help out when needed until after nine, but also enjoyed the opportunity to indulge in conversation with customers.

Obviously, this is the great joy of my line of work – people having a good time, eating, drinking, talking and enjoying life. It’s what a pub was intended to be.

During the last few months, many of these discussions have centered on what’s happening in New Albany. People from many walks of life are curious. They’ve heard rumors about a new eatery downtown – what can I tell them about it? They’re asking about the Greenway, about Scribner Place, and about all those nice old buildings downtown, who might use them, and how?

Significantly, a sizeable number of these people are not from New Albany. Louisvillians are asking these questions.

This week I received a phone call from overseas from a man who was born and raised in Southern Indiana and now is scouting possibilities to relocate here and open a business.

I provide information, try to answer questions, wave my arms a lot, and seek to perpetuate the notion as often as humanly possible that good things are happening in New Albany in part because there is an ever widening circle of people involved with the effort who are both talented and stubborn. They won’t take “no” for an answer.

There’s still doubt and skepticism, and understandably so given New Albany’s past level of often hermetic dysfunction.

However, the important thing to me is that at least some people are starting to believe in the possibilities, and while it may sound trite to paraphrase the sports analogy in such a manner, we’ll definitely miss out on 100% of the possibilities we don’t attempt to fulfill.

Obviously, nothing occurs overnight, but much groundwork has been laid during 2005. Strangely for me, I find myself in the “glass half full” camp for one of the first times in my life.

In 2006, there’ll be little time for the slander, rancor and hatred that characterizes the city’s professional nay-saying class; rather, their dead weight must be carried forward, like an unfortunate surcharge for progress – the price of doing business -- and what’s more, it must be borne happily by those of us who can see the possibilities inherent in the city of New Albany.

I’m damned optimistic. I hope you are, too.

Friday, December 16, 2005

'Tis the season for ... ACLU bashing?

In today's chapter of a week-long series that might have been entitled "A Season for Proselytizing," our friend Healthblogger returns to the topic of the American Civil Liberties Union and finds it a rhetorical straw man well worth bashing.

The ACLU has been the target of HB's wrath before, as in Who is the ACLU really fighting for? (November 19, 2005).

The organization's web site provides the answer to HB's question, listing these general areas of concern:

Criminal Justice, Death Penalty, Disability Rights, Drug Policy, Free Speech, FreedomWire/Youth, HIV/AIDS, Immigrants' Rights, Int'l Human Rights,
Lesbian & Gay Rights, National Security, Police Practices, Prisoners' Rights, Privacy & Technology, Racial Justice, Religious Liberty, Reproductive Freedom, Rights of the Poor, Safe and Free, Voting Rights, Women's Rights.

As for the ritualistic paranoia commonly dispensed this time of year with regard to the ACLU's "attacks" on Christmas, here's the other side of the coin, courtesy of http://www.aclu.org/.

----

How The ACLU Didn't Steal Christmas (12/7/2005)

By
Fran Quigley

Mr.
Quigley is executive director of the Indiana Civil Liberties Union, http://www.iclu.org/. As of January 1, 2006, the organization is changing its name to ACLU of Indiana.

When the angry phone calls and emails started arriving at the office, I knew the holiday season was upon us. A typical message shouted that we at the American Civil Liberties Union are "horrible" and "we should be ashamed of ourselves," and then concluded with an incongruous and agitated "Merry Christmas."

We get this type of correspondence a lot, mostly in reaction to a well-organized attempt by extremist groups to demonize the ACLU, crush religious diversity, and make a few bucks in the process. Sadly, this self-interested effort is being promoted in the guise of defending Christmas.

For example, the Alliance Defense Fund celebrates the season with an "It's OK to say Merry Christmas" campaign, implying that the ACLU has challenged such holiday greetings. (As part of the effort, you can get a pamphlet and two Christmas pins for $29.)

The website WorldNetDaily touts a book claiming "a thorough and virulent anti-Christmas campaign is being waged today by liberal activists and ACLU fanatics." The site's magazine has suggested there will be ACLU efforts to remove "In God We Trust" from U.S. currency, fire military chaplains, and expunge all references to God in America's founding documents. (Learn more for just $19.95 . . . )

Of course, there is no "Merry Christmas" lawsuit, nor is there any ACLU litigation about U.S. currency, military chaplains, etc. But the facts are not important to these groups, because their real message is this: By protecting the freedom of Muslims, Jews, and other non-Christians through preventing government entanglement with religion, the ACLU is somehow infringing on the rights of those with majority religious beliefs.

In truth, it is these website Christians who are taking the Christ out of the season. Nowhere in the Sermon on the Mount did Jesus Christ ask that we celebrate His birth with narrow-mindedness and intolerance, especially for those who are already marginalized and persecuted. Instead, the New Testament—like the Torah and the Koran and countless other sacred texts—commands us to love our neighbor, and to comfort the sick and the imprisoned.

That's what the ACLU does. We live in a country filled with people who are sick and disabled, people who are imprisoned, and people who hunger and thirst for justice. Those people come to our Indiana offices for help, at a rate of several hundred a week, usually because they have nowhere else to turn. The least of our brothers and sisters sure aren't getting any help from the Alliance Defense Fund or WorldNet Daily. So, as often as we can, ACLU secures justice for those folks who Jesus worried for the most.

As part of our justice mission, we work hard to protect the rights of free religious expression for all people, including Christians. For example, we recently defended the First Amendment rights of a Baptist minister to preach his message on public streets in southern Indiana. The ACLU intervened on behalf of a Christian valedictorian in a Michigan high school, which agreed to stop censoring religious yearbook entries, and supported the rights of Iowa students to distribute Christian literature at their school.

There are many more examples, because the ACLU is committed to preserving the constitutional guarantee of religious freedom for all. We agree with the U.S. Supreme Court's firm rulings that this freedom means that children who grow up in non-Christian homes should not be made to feel like outsiders in their own community's courthouse, legislature or public schoolhouse.

To our "Merry Christmas" correspondents and all other Hoosiers, we wish you happy holidays.

Thursday, December 15, 2005

Open thread: December 15, 2005 City Council meeting.

A short (35 minutes) and by the numbers meeting was highlighted by Mayor James Garner's "state of the city" review of the year 2005.

Will CM Dan Coffey be the next council president?

If so, will he resubscribe to the Tribune?

Vital questions of the day ...

Volunteer Hoosier reminds readers that "Rumpkegate Matters."

And we agree.

Rumpkegate Matters.

The shame of it is that the blogger who exposed Rupkegate still hasn't grasped the gravity of her revelation, and can't seem to understand that her constant and probably well-intentioned calls for integrity and honesty must apply to all elected officials, not merely the one whose administration is her daily target for intemperate abuse.

Hypocrisy's a big word with many syllables ... and it matters, too.

Early New Albany brewer and Scottish-American poet Hew Ainslie.

(Cross posted to Potable Curmudgeon)

This biographical sketch of Hew Ainslie, New Albany's first commercial brewer, was written by Louisville goldsmith, writer and homebrewer Conrad Selle, with editing by RAB, and originally was published in the FOSSILS newsletter circa 1994. Later it was a staple on the club's web site, but when the site changed web hosts last year it disappeared.

I located it on a back-up zip disk. Many thanks to Conrad, whose tireless research into Louisville area brewing can be experienced in Louisville Breweries, co-written with Peter Guetig.

Many early brewers worked their trade as a sideline or temporary trade before moving on to other occupations. Hew Ainslie is unique for having been principally a poet.

He was born at Bargany in Ayrshire, Scotland on April 5, 1792. Hew was the only son of George Ainslie, an employee on the estate of Sir Hew Dalrymple Hamilton. He was educated in the parish school at Ballantrae, and later at the academy at Ayr. In 1809 his family moved to Roslin, about six miles from Edinburgh. He married his cousin Janet Ainslie in 1812, whose brother Jock had married Hew's sister Eleanora.

Ainslie studied law in Glasgow, and worked as a clerk in the Register House in Edinburgh. In 1820 he revisited Ayrshire on foot with James Wellstood and John Gibson and in the next two years wrote A Pilgrimage to the Land of Burns, which was published in London in 1822. The book was an account of their travels and visits with some of Robert Burns's contemporaries, with songs and ballads by Ainslie that were much in the style of Burns, and illustrations by Wellstood.

In July, 1822, Ainslie sailed from Liverpool to New York with his friend Wellstood. Mrs. Ainslie and their three children joined him in the following year. Ainslie and Wellstood purchased Pilgrim's Repose, a farm at Hoosac Falls in Rensselaer County, New York. Ainslie and his family lived there for almost three years before joining Robert Owen's utopian socialist cooperative community at New Harmony, Indiana in 1825.

When Owen's community failed about a year later they moved first to Cincinnati, where Ainslie became a partner with Price and (Thomas) Wood in a brewery, then to Louisville. In Louisville, a town of 7,000, Ainslie opened a brewery in 1829 at 7th Street between Water and Main. Records show that B. Foster, Enoch Wenzell and Robert McKenzie worked there.

In February, 1832 there was a major flood of the Ohio River, with the river's waters rising to 46 feet above the low water level. A contemporary account of the "calamity" reads:

This was an unparalleled flood in the Ohio. It commenced on the 10th of February and continued until the 21st of that month, having risen to (an) extraordinary height ... above low-water mark. The destruction of property by this flood was immense. Nearly all the frame buildings near the river were either floated off or turned over and destroyed. An almost total cessation in business was the necessary consequence; even farmers from the neighborhood were unable to get to the markets, the flood having so affected the smaller streams as to render them impassable. The description of the sufferings by this flood is appalling ...

Ainslie's brewery was swept away with most of the neighborhood, but in the following years he remained in the beer business, working at the Nuttall brewery on the west side of 6th Street between Water and Main.

In 1840 he opened the first brewery in New Albany, the partnership of Bottomley & Ainslie. Soon that business was destroyed by fire. In the 1841 Louisville City Directory, Hew Ainslie is listed as a maltster; it was his last listing in the brewing trade. Discouraged by fire and flood, he gave up the brewing business altogether. Thereafter, his working life became somewhat intertwined with that of his children, particularly George and James Wellstood Ainslie.

Hew and Janet Ainslie had ten children, seven of them surviving to adulthood. George Ainslie, the eldest Ainslie son, had been apprenticed to Lachan McDougall around 1830 to learn the iron foundry and moulding trade, and he had acquired a solid business and technical education. He became a foreman at John Curry's foundry and married Mary Thirlwell, daughter of Charles Thirlwell, who was a brewer at the Nuttall Brewery (Hew Ainslie's one-time employer).

Thirlwell eventually acquired Nuttall and operated it until 1856. In 1842, George Ainslie became a partner in Gowan and McGhee's Boone Foundry. By 1845 Hew Ainslie -- still a poet throughout -- was employed as a finisher there as well as working as a contractor and in the building trades.

George and James Ainslie became highly successful in the foundry and machine business, enabling their father to devote more time to writing in later life. In 1853, Hew Ainslie made a long visit to New Jersey to visit members of the family of James Wellstood, undoubtedly providing the poet with a nostalgic link to the Scotland of his youth.

In 1855 a collection of Ainslie's verse, Scottish Songs, Ballads and Poetry, was published in New York. One latter-day commentator called Ainslie's songs of the sea "the best that Scotland has produced," and perhaps this assessment was borne out by the reception accorded Ainslie in Scottish literary circles in 1863, when he returned to Scotland for a final visit.

Janet Ainslie died in 1863 prior to Hew's last Scottish journey. In 1868 the elderly poet/brewer went to live with his son George in a new home on Chestnut Street (between 9th and 10th) in Louisville, where he spent the last decade of his life and was a familiar sight as he passed time tending the garden there. Ainslie died on March 6, 1878, and was eulogized in the Courier-Journal as "a poet of considerable merit to the people of his native land." Hew and Janet Ainslie are buried in Cave Hill Cemetery.

In addition to the many accomplishments noted previously, Ainslie is remembered for his height -- at 6 feet, 4 inches, he referred to himself in his works as "The Lang Linker" -- and for never losing his Scottish accent during almost six decades in America.

There is no specific information to be found as to the products of the breweries with which Hew Ainslie was involved in Louisville and New Albany, but we can surmise from the available evidence that they were typical small breweries of the time, with four or five employees, making ale, porter and stout. As a man who appreciated truth and beauty, it is likely that Hew Ainslie made good malt, and being conscientious with it, good beer as well.

The following poems by Hew Ainslie are copied from the Filson Historical Society's extremely rare copy of A Pilgrimage to the Land of Burns and Poetry, Ainslie's 1822 work combined with later efforts and reprinted in 1892, the centenary of his birth.

(Author's note: I have heard a scrap or two of Robert Burns, and expect these are much better read aloud in Scots dialect.)

THE DAFT DAYS.

The midnight hour is clinking, lads,
An' the douce an' the decent are winking, lads;
Sae I tell ye again,
Be't weel or ill ta'en,
It's time ye were quatting your drinking, lads.
Gae ben, 'an mind your gauntry, Kate,
Gi'es mair o' your beer, an' less bantry, Kate,
For we vow, whaur we sit,
That afore we shall flit,
We'se be better acquaint wi' your pantry, Kate.
The "daft days" are but beginning, Kate,
An we're sworn. Would you hae us a sinning, Kate?
By our faith an' our houp,
We will stick by the stoup
As lang as the barrel keeps rinning, Kate.
Thro' hay, an' thro' hairst, sair we toil it, Kate,
Thro' Simmer, an' Winter, we moil it, Kate;
Sae ye ken, whan the wheel
Is beginning to squeal,
It's time for to grease an' to oil it, Kate.
Sae draw us anither drappy, Kate,
An' gie us a cake to our cappy, Kate;
For, by spiggot an' pin!
It's waur than a sin
To flit when we're sitting sae happy, Kate.

LET'S DRINK TO OUR NEXT MEETING.

Let's drink to our next meeting, lads,
Nor think on what's atwixt;
They're fools wha spoil the present hour
By thinking on the next.
Then here's to Meg o' Morningside,
An Kate o' Kittlemark;
The taen she drank her hose and shoon,
The tither pawned her sark.
A load o' wealth, an' wardly pelf,
They say is sair to bear;
Sae he's a gowk would scrape an' howk
To make his burden mair

Then here's , &c.
Gif Care looks black the morn, lads,

As he's come doon the lum,
Let's ease our hearts by swearing, lads,
We never bade him come.
Then here's, &c.
Then here's to our next meeting, lads,
Ne'er think on what's atwixt;
They're fools who spoil the present hour
By thinking on the next.
Then here's, &c.

THE HOOSIER .

We lads that live up in the nobs,
Tho' our manners might yet bear a rubbing,
We're handy at neat little jobs
Such as chopping and hewing and grubbing.
Tho' we roost in a cabin of logs,
And clapboards lie 'twixt us and heaven,
Our mast makes us fine oily hogs,
And from hoop-poles we pick a good living.
Right quiet -- to a decent degree --
it's seldom we guzzle it deep, Sir,
Tho' we don't mind a bit of a spree,
Provided the liquor is cheap, Sir.
Our neighbours, that live 'cross the drink.
May laugh at our fondness for cider,
But so long as we pocket their clink
They may laugh till their mouths they grow wider.
Our gals make our trousers, you see,
From that beautiful stuff called tow linen,
and in coats of the linsey -- dang me,
If we don't look both handsome and winning.
Our wives are our weavers, to boot;
Ourselves are first rate on a shoe, Sir;
We can doctor a tub with a hoop --
And hark ! we're our own niggers too, Sir,
So here's to our Hoosier land,
The sons of its soil and its waters !
May the "nullies" ne'er get it in hand,
Nor demagogues tear it in tatters.
But still may it flourish and push,
Thro' vetos and all such tough cases,
Till railroads are common as brush,
And the nobs are as sleek as your faces.

Conrad thinks that the "The Hoosier" was intended as an anti-nullification poem -- a slap at the slave-owning caste south of the Ohio River, and a self-mocking espousal of the poor but free residents to the north. If any reader can shed further light on the history involved, please do.

Wednesday, December 14, 2005

We'll hold you to it.

How will SOLNA survive?

“Until I can offer some rational statements in regards to these situations, I am staying off the blog.”

East Ender (Laura Oates) 5:14 PM, December 14, 2005.

Trash removal takes on a whole new meaning when applied to the sources of Luddite dysfunction.

NA Confidential understands perfectly well that for some loyal readers, there is a degree of puzzlement, and perhaps even exasperation, as to why we've chosen to devote much of the week's postings to the semi-literate and ill-tempered blathering of New Albany's politically motivated obstructionists.

All things considered, it remains our preference to chart, consider and document the gratifyingly steady progress taking place in New Albany, as the long slumbering city deliberately but tangibly inches toward an overdue reawakening and an improved future, thanks in large measure to the Herculean efforts of a diverse array of people who share an earnest commitment to excellence in life.

Given this preference, it is with confidence and equanimity that we urge any and all rational, thinking people to survey at their leisure the year's contents of NA Confidential -- our missteps alongside our successes -- and to compare the range of topical inquiry and depth of substance here with that offered to the public at other, seedier locales on the information superhighway that purport to "speak out loud," but in fact manage little else than the empowerment of spite, envy and retribution.

As such, when it comes to the admittedly odious task of drawing back the obscurantist curtains of churlish anonymity and exposing the desolation that resides within, we at NA Confidential persist in doing so out of nothing more than an admittedly stubborn sense of personal obligation that expressions of hatred, falsehood and malevolence must neither go unanswered nor unchallenged in a civilized society, whatever the risks involved in the process.

With New Albany approaching an historical crossroads, and as a window of opportunity is nudged temporarily open for those with the requisite qualities of vision and foresight to burst through to the other side, it is absolutely imperative for the current generation of city residents, as well as the critical eye of posterity, to be perfectly clear about the nature of New Albany's enduring, seemingly reform-resistant dysfunction, and to know exactly from whence this crippling malady derives.

It derives from anti-intellectualism.

It is plain to see that this group of newcomers to New Albany want to run over the New Albany citizens like a steam roller with their type of speech and language.*

It derives from xenophobia.

How long have you been a resident of New Albany?*

It derives from racism, homophobia and intolerance.

Go to the History books on New Albany and try to realize that those ancestors were caring people, not of the caliber that we see here today ... To the person who wanted to know about the Director of City Operations' sealed records, you may have to re-visit the ex-County Prosecutor -- ask him, or maybe Krogers.*

It derives from a resigned acceptance of social stratification.

The biggest determination of where a person winds up in life, is the situation of the life one was born into.*

It derives from the calculating ward-heeler's Pavlovian politics of malice and reward, and from the angry populist's elemental thirst for revenge (see Cappuccino, Councilman), but worst of all, it derives from the sullen sum total of all these conditions mixed together into a nasty sludge far more virulent than crystal meth, pointing inexorably toward a demoralizing, non-quality of subsistence living that virtually guarantees that our best and brightest will flee into the friendlier and more hopeful embrace of the New Albanian diaspora throughout greater North America.

To be sure, during times of relative thaw, NA Confidential has been told -- and, in fact, desperately wants to believe -- that "we're all in this together."

Alas, this is true only in the strictest sense of physical proximity.

In terms of civic consciousness ... in terms of vision ... in terms of respect for the rules ... the chasm remains sadly deep.

Unapologetically, we intend to continue presenting the case for progress in New Albany -- to us, "progress" is defined as "intelligent design" -- and to do so by positively depicting the visionary components of a better future for all New Albanians, while refusing to shrink from the duty of shining bright, disinfectant sunlight onto the destructive, self-defeating dogmas of defeatist regression that represent huge strides backward for this city.

Thank you for reading, and please consider registering and joining the conversation.

Further reading at NA Confidential:

Overt anti-intellectualism? Well, that would explain CM Price's votes against the interests of his own district.

Tiny is as tiny does, or a level of the Inferno that Dante overlooked.

On the nature of lawlessness, the motivations of looters, and the pernicious influence of hatred in our community.

Is New Albany's anti-intellectualism spiced with homophobia?

---

* - italicized portions are from the comments section of the SOLNA blog, as if that weren't painfully obvious.

Mayor Garner's sanitation solution is a good one for the whole community.

New Albany’s Great Sanitation Debate of 2005 probably will exhibit a half-life of at least 23 months, stretching through the general election of 2007, at which time the efficient, technocratic privatization of our formerly city-run sanitation service will be portrayed by a motley collection of local extremists as roughly commensurate with the St. Valentine’s Day massacre ordered by Al Capone, or worst yet in the eyes of our braying native obstructionists, the city council vote in favor of Scribner Place.

The unspeakable horror of progress ...

We may expect these tattered Bloody Shirts to be waved with steadily lessening vigor for many years to come, long after the city’s current sanitation department has been absorbed en masse by Clark-Floyd Landfill LLC/Eco-Tech LLC and it becomes clear that the majority of New Albany residents have not chosen to stake the future of the city on the solitary issue of garbage collection, and longer still after Scribner Place has become an accepted and much utilized component of a revitalized downtown.

NA Confidential confines its comments to noting with respect and pleasure that an activist mayor has endured the crass politicization of an important issue, ducked the salvos of mud slung by those doing the politicizing, sifted through enormous collections of facts and figures, resolved the pressing problem of a congenitally dysfunctional city department, and done so in a manner that will not result in a loss of jobs.

That’s an exemplary way to earn one’s pay.

And where were the city council’s Duke Boys, Dan Coffey and Steve Price, during all this? We seem to recall a secret plan, although it may be that they're saving the pumpkin patch (and Whitaker Chambers) for future use in their re-election campaigns.

There remains the significant matter of Rumpkegate and the possibly felonious (and palpably false) sanitation bid "leaks" dribbled by a councilman or confederate to a trusting fellow blogger, who continues to spin Fortuna's Wheel on a daily basis with regard to her "official" account of the tawdry ethical lapse that she herself prompted through an unseemly eagerness to be viewed as an insider.

Actually, to our way of thinking, perhaps the single most welcomed ethical aftereffect of the sanitation changeover lies in the long overdue removal of a department that traditionally has been a wild and wooly refuge for political patronage of the old-fashioned sort that appeals with maximum sentimentality to the unreconstructed ward heelers among local politicos.

Could it be that the motives of at least some of the movers and shakers actively seeking to be depicted as knights in shining armor, heroically riding to the rescue of the besieged sanitation department, always had more to do with the impending cost to their own political influence, especially in the context of future political campaigns, and far less with the welfare of the workers?

Jus' R 'pinion, mind you.

----

Side note 1: All ex-aides to former mayors are invited to join the discussion. We're all here to learn.

Side note 2: $$$$$$$$, does this adequately answer your "fiefdom" question? I've just been waiting for a good time, and fearing that I'd be censored in yonder spitwad blogyard.

Tuesday, December 13, 2005

UPDATED: Board of Public Works Flash: Clark Floyd LLC/Eco-Tech LLC awarded sanitation contract.

From roving correspondent Tim Deatrick:

The winning bid for sanitation was just announced, drum roll please Clark Floyd LLC/Eco-Tech LLC!

Thanks Tim.

For more, visit Volunteer Hoosier and New Albany Today.

NA Confidential is off to work.

Just how low/Will a troglodyte go/When a troglodyte’s going low?

The Dead Pee Scrolls – those Priceful snippets of graffiti inscribed with greasy crayon stubs on the battered drywall above the reeking urinals of New Albany’s Luddite Bar & Grill – proliferate bunny-like at the conclusion of the darkened tavern’s daily Morose Hour, as the sullen, hooded patrons drain their final, discounted Old Swillwaukees and begin to feel the unholy ache of their unrequited bile, which angrily, and inarticulately, rises to a crescendo as the official Luddite Karaoke machine begins humming to the tune of “Trog Sham(an)’s Blues.”

Meanwhile, since last Monday’s city council meeting …

An empty chair's better than an empty suit -- or why Frankfort Avenue is bad for an Uncouncilman's stunted imagination.

… the perennial obstructionist’s pot of misinformation has been at full simmer, with the Gang of Four’s overworked, fact-manufacturing apologists first baffled, then piously outraged, that juicy gossip emanating from one of their own (EastdistEnded) suddenly was being viewed by thinking people as potentially incriminating to one or more pairs of loose council lips:

The council member's Rumpke bid lie: It is an ethical lapse, and it does matter.

Inspired by the ricocheting venom, yesterday NA Confidential proceeded to ask:

Why wade ankle-deep through antisocial bile dispensed by semi-literate, hooded character assassins morbidly deploying the purely errant rationale that their own deep-seated anger and eternal unhappiness constitute desired ways of living that the remainder of the local populace must somehow be bludgeoned into accepting as preconditions of life here?

As you will read below, the answer wasn’t long in coming.

Are you ready? It’s because NAC is drunk.

And you’re still wondering why this is so much fun?

Therefore, in the spirit of fairness – and because NA Confidential persists in believing that unfettered sunlight remains the very best disinfectant of all – here are a few comments in “response” to NAC, as offered during the past 24 hours at the spitwad blogyard, which is defended by its proprietor as necessary to assist the terminally and maliciously anonymous in overcoming their mortal fear of being exposed as the cowards they really are, and who deems the following somehow to be worthy contributions to the municipal dialogue.

PARENTAL WARNING: While SOLNA postings often serve as a sadly necessary reference source for those exploring the origins of malice, be aware that the sheer acrimony on regular display there alarmingly testifies to the ubiquity of the worst angels of our nature as human beings. It isn't pretty. Please monitor your child's web surfing accordingly.

First, she who jokingly claims to prohibit personal attacks (audible chortling) kicks things off by viciously sliming a councilman:

To read more about official accounts of sanitation discussions, and political manuvering, on the part of one of the Mayor's goon squad, Donnie Blevins, use the link on the front page and go to the City Clerks web site and look up Council minutes of Sept. 8th, 2005 ... By East Ender, at 3:43 PM, December 12, 2005

Frequent SOLNA target Tony Toran, a minister whose very commitment to Christianity previously has been dismissed by Ms. Oates’s “mad as hell” readers, and inexplicably defended by her as relevant, is next up for the “screaming” treatment:

PEOPLE NEED TO WONDER WHY THEY HAVE SEALED TONY TORANS RECORDS! FACT OR FICTION? … By Anonymous, at 9:08 PM, December 12, 2005

Clear away the appetizers – it’s time for the epiphet-laden “we don’t need no educashion” cultist:

Hey Rog, what in the hell are you talking about with all that mumble-jumble on your spitwad? You seem to forget that Laura is just one of MANY who speak out loud! Seems to me that you are the one that is paranoid and conspiring against people that have got your number. The citizens of New Albany don't have to use all those fancy words to get their point across. You seem to get soooo many comments at your rag because, of course, you are always right.(?)

Why can't you keep it civil instead of attacking all the time? What the hell is up with the "spitwad-blogyard" title anyway? For someone who professes to be so educated you sure do resort to a lot of elementary shool yard bullying. Gimme a Break!

Why can't you just talk about the issues and respond with civil comments that pertain to the issues at hand. By the way I would be careful on who you are calling a liar. Just a bit of educated advice. Have a nice day.

p.s. BULLY- One who is habitually cruel ... By fed up taxpayer, at
11:09 PM, December 12, 2005

Hey, “fed up,” the only person we’ve ever called out for lying is “conceal taxpayer” – and that’s only because she told a huge whopper once and never retracted it. We expect her apology any day now, but until then, here’s solemn testimony from another of your courageous SOLNA blogger buddies:

Alcoholism is a serious disease. The first ability or sense to leave your body would be your sense of judgment. Please, I would urge all of you to keep this mind when you read and hear the character assassinations here, and on the other blogs …

… Keep in mind how sick alcoholics are, and that may help you understand the ramblings of what I call and read on here "an educated fool". What a waste of a human being. This is only my opinion, though ... By In The Know, & Tired Of It!!!, at 12:50 AM, December 13, 2005

That one really hurt! I’d drink one of my $10 progressive pints to ease the pain, but it isn’t noon yet – but then again, it must be noon somewhere, eh, “In the Know”?

Finally, for broad comic relief, here’s a bit of the ever so obvious:

all4words and randy smith is the same person. Don't let these other people try to fool us with all the attacks. Keep throwing all the truth out here Laura and all the "Speak Out Loud NA" citizens. People are getting awful nervous about alot of your comments ... By Anonymous, at 6:35 AM, December 13, 2005

Not nervous, anonymous.

They’re laughing at you.

Monday, December 12, 2005

Tiny is as tiny does, or a level of the Inferno that Dante overlooked.

"The first and best victory is to conquer self; to be conquered by self is, of all things, the most shameful and vile."
-- Plato


More than two thousand years later, what is the condition of the New Albanian municipal agora?

We visited one street corner yesterday, meaning to find out.

Excuse me – can you point out New Albany’s grassy knoll?

In search of amusement on a dreary December Sunday afternoon, NA Confidential donned its prophylactic body suit, borrowed from the Fire Department’s meth lab unit, and ventured into the dank and reeking confines of the notorious spitwad blogyard, there to stoke the promiscuous opprobrium of the masked and drool-stained inhabitants within.

Later, mission accomplished, we withdrew to enjoy a shower and a smoke.

As many readers have asked: Why?

Why wade ankle-deep through antisocial bile dispensed by semi-literate, hooded character assassins morbidly deploying the purely errant rationale that their own deep-seated anger and eternal unhappiness constitute desired ways of living that the remainder of the local populace must somehow be bludgeoned into accepting as preconditions of life here?

Why bother?

Because it’s great fun, of course, but far more importantly, it owes to the obligation to present an opposing viewpoint – even while dodging the inevitable mud flung by those who profess to venerate "the rules" and yet can’t quite bring themselves to learn what those rules are, and what they imply for thinking, responsible people.

That ol’ “no can do” spirit.

New Albanians are an enduringly curious lot.

For long decades, many of them have been conditioned by previous addled generations to accept as a bizarre corollary to the social contract the utterly mistaken proposition that their city is incapable of achievement of the sort that can be plainly glimpsed in so many other locales of similar size and circumstance.

Worst yet, having grasped as gospel something that is palpably false, they proceed to derive a deeply ingrained civic inferiority complex from this father-to-son inability to envision excellence – hence their eternal mistrust of “outsiders,” who arrive in New Albany happily unencumbered by the ruinous psychological baggage of defeatism and self-loathing, and consequently run the constant risk of engendering cognitive dissonance amongst the sullen, spiteful natives by seeking accomplishment and often, against all odds, maintaining it.

And, needless to say, seldom if ever being accepted by the nay-saying local apostles of failure and denigration.

Meanwhile, a cult of numbers.

Numerology, as defined by http://www.dictionary.com/, is “the study of the occult meanings of numbers and their supposed influence on human life.”

Occult meanderings, superstition, hearsay, conspiracy, dysfunction and unrequited obsessions – these are the choking weeds that grow in the barren vacuum where education has failed to take root.

For the record, NA Confidential does not subscribe to the notion perpetuated by the sewage numerologists among us that raw columns of numbers add up to any semblance of ultimate truth beyond the limited applications for which they have been intended.

This does not mean that we dismiss the utility of balancing the household checkbook, of audits and accountants, or of the necessity of following prescribed financial procedures, but merely that these useful aspects of human affairs are forever and always proportional to the myriad intangibles in life – those human qualities like courage, will, resolve, confidence and leadership, that directly equate to achievement in this world, here and now.

Shameful politics of the low common denominator.

According to the writer A. Lou Vickery,

Nothing average ever stood as a monument to progress. When progress is looking for a partner it doesn't turn to those who believe they are only average. It turns instead to those who are forever searching and striving to become the best they possibly can. If we seek the average level we cannot hope to achieve a high level of success. Our only hope is to avoid being a failure.

Of all the attitudinal impediments to the realization of potential, whether personal or in a group setting, the acceptance and subsequent glorification of the average certainly must be worst, especially when accompanied by a perception of inferiority that manifests itself in contempt for the prerequisites of success.

NA Confidential believes that these damaging dispositions are prime examples of learned behavior, and that they can be overcome, if not easily and quickly, both by individuals and my municipal entities. We believe they must be overcome if we are to improve the future prospects of the city of New Albany.

But they are unlikely to be overcome by a slavish devotion to numerology that seeks nirvana in the decade-old sewer audit, or though anonymous attacks on those who are known, capable and willing to recognize what is possible when talent is rewarded, not blamed, and blamed for no better reason than the inability of the troglodyte barnacle wobbling his or her finger to fathom what it means to fulfill potential.

Dysfunction is a virulent condition in which seemingly irreconcilable problems comprise a “devil you know” universe of chaos and drift, and potential solutions represent unacceptable attacks on the “natural” order of things.

NA Confidential begs to differ in the strongest possible terms, by agreeing with the late John Lennon that there are no problems – only solutions.

But, in the end, the victims of dysfunction must want to get better.

Will ours?

Or must we all stoop to that level of sheer futility?