Showing posts with label shared space. Show all posts
Showing posts with label shared space. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 28, 2019

Pedestrians and bicyclists in Amsterdam -- and Deaf Gahan's Nawbany.


On Monday I was walking down the sidewalk on the south side of Market when I saw a bicyclist riding down the sidewalk toward me. At this time of the morning there were no cars whatever on Market, and yet there she was, so I politely asked if she would stop for just a moment and entertain a question or three in the interest of science, and she was amenable.

From a former to a current bicycle rider, do you always ride on the sidewalk?

"Yes, almost always," she said.

But shouldn't bikes be on the street?

"It isn't safe out there -- there's no bike lane."

There's a bike lane on Spring Street.

"Sort of. The traffic still moves too fast, and anyway the bike lane ends and I'm back on the sidewalk again."

What do you think of sharrows?

"You used to ride a bike? Then you know sharrows aren't safe."

---

I thanked her and kept walking, confident that this brief conversation of two or three minutes was two or three minutes linger than any chat ever held between Jeff Gahan's inept minions, his corrupt contractors and a real human being on an actual bicycle.

By the way, there are problems in Amsterdam, too.

Can Amsterdam’s Cyclists and Pedestrians Learn to Get Along? by Sophie Knight (CityLab)

As Amsterdammers jostle for space, the city government is trying to ease conflicts between those on bikes and on foot.

Urbanists around the world swoon over Amsterdam’s cycling culture: residents trundling around cobbled streets with a child balanced on their handlebars or a friend on the back, everyone blissfully free from the road rage that infects car-heavy cities such as London and New York. What’s not to like?

Well, a few things, if you’re a pedestrian. An oncoming cyclist may barrel through a red light or crosswalk or suddenly swerve onto the sidewalk. Cyclists in Amsterdam often park their bikes haphazardly, cluttering street corners and blocking the passage of strollers, wheelchairs, and suitcase-bearing tourists.

And woe betide those who accidentally step onto a bike path. “This is Amsterdam!” is one of the kinder reactions.

“Cyclists are even more antisocial than drivers,” complains Jennifer Brouwer, 37, who is registered blind and who moved to the city’s quieter outskirts from its busy West district because she was tired of conflicts with cyclists. “They’re more likely to think, ‘Oh, I can get away with that,’ like cutting people up, cycling a hair’s breadth away from you… There is just no enforcement.”

Efforts to educate cyclists or tame two-wheelers are met with opprobrium in anti-authoritarian Amsterdam, according to “street coaches” hired by the city to do so. Nevertheless, the local government is trying to balance the needs of cyclists and pedestrians. Aware of pressure on public space as the city’s population swells, the municipality said in 2017 it would prioritize both groups, not just cyclists, in its five-year Bicycle Plan starting that year ...

Saturday, August 24, 2019

Charles Marohn went to Paris and learned a lot of simple things that elude us in America.


"I’m not suggesting it would be easy or straightforward for North American cities to become Paris, but as my friend John Anderson has said many times, we don’t need to be Paris, we just need to be a slightly less crappy version of America."

I've trimmed this down a bit, hoping Marohn doesn't mind that I've left his five central observations intact.

---

The Streets of Paris, by Charles Marohn (Strong Towns)

1. Street Trees
Especially here in my hometown, I’m constantly hearing how we can’t have street trees, largely for maintenance reasons. The leaves drop and mess up the drainage. The roots damage the pipes. They are in the way for people in wheelchairs. Car drivers will hit them. And my favorite: If we ever need to widen the street, they are in the way.

And, of course, there is the persistent criticism of street trees: They won’t grow. My response to all of these criticisms has been to point to amazing places full of street trees and say, “If they can do it, why can’t we?” Paris is full of street trees, and it has been doing it successfully for a lot longer than any modern North American city has existed.

2. Ubiquitous Bollards
In the United States, our civil engineers often insist on a clear zone on each side of the street. You can ‘t place anything in the clear zone because, by the theory of Forgiving Design, if an automobile is driven off the driving surface, the sudden stop from hitting a fixed object will harm the driver and any passengers of the vehicle. This thinking is rightfully applied to highways and areas where we want traffic to move fast without the potential for conflict. When we apply Forgiving Design to local streets, though, we get absurdities like breakaway light poles along sidewalks. There isn’t a clearer statement of the North American engineer’s values than that.

I actually encountered an engineer once that didn’t allow a sandwich board sign because of the hazard it presented to automobiles should they strike it.

Needless to say, Paris has gone far in the opposite direction. Seemingly everywhere a vehicle could operate at speeds that would injure people, they have erected obstacles to keep the errant car from striking a human. Absorbing the kinetic energy of a collision is the responsibility of the car and driver, not the people walking along the street. This is cheap, easy, and really effective.

3. Narrow Streets
In the United States, we use transportation funding as a mechanism to address public safety concerns. Our fire departments often operate on the theory that if you can respond to an emergency quickly, the public is safer. European countries have a much different approach, one that emphasizes prevention over response time. Here in the United States, we require wide lanes, wide shoulders and wide clear zones along our streets so that emergency response vehicles travel unhindered to any emergency. The concept of a clear zone is ridiculous in Paris.

I’ll note that you are far less likely to die in a fire in a European city than an American one. Ditto a traffic collision. Two of our classic Strong Towns memes apply here.

4. Slip Lanes
When a design prioritizes building wealth in a place instead of moving traffic, the basic geometry of the public space shifts. In terms of wealth creation, I really like how this street is designed. There is human space on the edge; wide enough for two people to walk side-by-side and meet a pair doing likewise coming from the opposite direction. They are protected by bollards along the entire stretch. Then there is a one-way slip lane for drivers seeking a place to park a vehicle — these lanes are constrained to ensure slow speeds. Then there is a parking lane, although with a decent amount of that space given over to scooters and bikes. Then a boulevard to provide some vertical framing for the street in the form of street trees and nice lighting. The center has two driving lanes with opposing flow, and then it all repeats along the other side.

For cities that want to make their stroads into wealth-creating streets, this is a great cross section to utilize.

5. Shared Space Intersections

Finally, I’m a huge fan of shared space intersections—intersections that lack traffic markings, including stop signs or traffic signals—and I ran into a great one in Versailles. With tired kids and wife, I didn’t get to linger as long as I would have liked to, but in the short time I was there, I did see the humane mingling of humans and vehicles induced by slow speeds and the more chaotic design.

The idea of a chaotic design is anathema to everything North American engineering practice stands for, yet when drivers are less sure of their own path—let alone the path of others—they do remarkable things like slow down, look people in the eye, and yield. It’s a beautiful thing to watch; it’s just too bad there are so few examples here in the United States.

Thursday, April 06, 2017

A woonerf in Minneapolis: “Parking becomes a horrible but necessary land use but that will change over time."

Much more on woonerfs here.

It appears to be an improvement on the surface parking asphalt extravaganza existing there before, although a bit of the point surely was lost in translation. Have you stopped to consider that many of the urban conditions we complain about owe their existence to the necessity of accommodating our cars?

Is Minneapolis' first 'woonerf' really just a nice looking parking lot? by Peter Callaghan (MinnPost)

Minneapolis has its first woonerf. Or does it?

For those who aren’t on a planning commission or land-use groupies: A woonerf is a Dutch import that translates as “living street” (sometimes “living yard”) and is a hot topic in urban design and planning these days. It describes a mixed-use street or alleyway that is shared by cars, bicyclists and pedestrians — but without the strict delineation of traditional roads: sidewalks, bike lanes, traffic lanes, etc. — as a way to use limited space for multiple functions.

“For residents of a woonerf, the public space in front of their homes is a place to play, socialize, and, engage in the community,” noted the byDesign blog.

When it comes to Minneapolis’ first woonerf, however, it might be hard to envision such an idyllic scene. The path cuts diagonally between two new residential buildings — the affordable-housing apartment building Mill City Quarter and the market-rate senior apartments Abiitan Mill City — on South Second Street in downtown Minneapolis. And the new space is devoted, mostly, to 80 head-in parking stalls.

“Today it’s probably best characterized as a nice parking lot, a REALLY nice parking lot,” said Michael Schroeder, the assistant superintendent for planning at the Minneapolis Park and Recreation Board, which has signed off on the woonerf as part of the land deal governing the development.

All of which has raised the question: Is Minneapolis’ first woonerf woonerf-y enough to actually be called a woonerf?

Sunday, October 16, 2016

Superblocks in Barcelona, with a twist.

From the article.


Let's see who is the first to notice why this is a posting atypical of me.

Superblocks: how Barcelona is taking city streets back from cars, updated by David Roberts (Vox)

Modern cities are ruled by cars. Streets are designed for them; bikers, pedestrians, vendors, hangers-out, and all other forms of human life are pushed to the perimeter in narrow lanes or sidewalks. Truly shared spaces are confined to parks and the occasional plaza. This is such a fundamental reality of cities that we barely notice it any more.

Some folks, however, still cling to the old idea that cities are for people, that more common space should be devoted to living in the city rather than getting through it or around it.

But once you’ve got a city that’s mostly composed of street grids, devoted to moving cars around, how do you take it back? How can cities be reclaimed for people?

The city of Barcelona has come up with one incredibly clever solution to that problem.

It’s a bird ... it’s a plane ... it’s SUPERBLOCK

Saturday, August 09, 2014

"Cyclists, slow down. Pedestrians, move out of the way. Share the bridge!"


As Ryan Rogers presciently observed:

Bicyclists and pedestrians have been cohabiting the Brooklyn and Manhattan Bridges in NYC for a long time.

That's true, Ryan, but here in Indyucky, there must be a long, slow learning curve when entirely new ways of thinking come at us like so many alien space ships brazenly landing atop the Creation Museum.

First there was a "threat" to make cyclists walk the Big Four Bridge, then there wasn't. Louisville Waterfront Park has addressed the teapot tempest with two posts at its Fb page. As a public service, here they are, in their entirety.

Just a few words about one of the most popular venues in Waterfront Park - the Big Four Bridge. The Big Four Pedestrian/Bicycle Bridge.

Can't we all just get along? Pedestrians - be aware that you are sharing the bridge with cyclists. Cyclists - be aware that you are sharing the bridge with pedestrians. Everyone - be considerate of those who share the space with you!

The bridge is a unique space. It shares uses as well as users. It is not just a traditional commuter path - it is also a recreational path and a park space. It isn't just a way to get from Point A to Point B - it's also a scenic overlook, a social occasion. That means cyclists aren't going to be able to treat it like an expressway - they need to think of it more like a school zone and slow down. And pedestrians - be like the little school kids and remember what your mom and dad taught you - look both ways before crossing. Also, keep an eye on your kids. That cyclist wants to avoid an accident just as much as you do!

Pedestrians - the cyclists aren't being rude when they ring those little bells or call out from behind you - they are letting you know they are there - just scoot over and let them by.

Pedestrians - please don't walk 4 or 5 or 6 abreast. The space is simply not wide enough for this. You are blocking other users - cyclists and pedestrians - from getting by. Think how irritated you get in the grocery store when people park their carts in the middle of the aisle and then stand beside them and talk. Don't be those aisle-blocking cart people.

There has been rudeness on both sides. That needs to stop. Everyone, just slow down, take a deep breath, and accept that during busy times it's going to take a bit longer to get from one end to the other. Be patient! This bridge is for everyone to enjoy - young and old, fit and (ahem) not so fit (ok, that's me. ), differently-abled, wheels and no wheels. Please, let's not make anyone feel unwelcome or uncomfortable about using the bridge.

It's simple. Be aware. Be considerate. Enjoy the space and let it be enjoyable for others. Cyclists, slow down. Pedestrians, move out of the way. Share the bridge!

That is all.

So, to recap and be absolutely clear: YES!!! Bikes are still allowed on the Big Four Pedestrian/Bicycle Bridge. NO!!!! You don't have to walk your bikes across. Please, everyone, just be considerate of those around you, and enjoy the bridge! (I know I'm using a lot of !!!!!, but somehow I feel like I'm not being heard today. )
And now, for the hardest part of all: Once you've learned Big Four Bridge etiquette, try not to forget that the very same guidelines apply when walking, biking or DRIVING YOUR CAR anywhere else ... even when YOU'RE NOT ON THE BIG FOUR BRIDGE.

Got it? Now, take it away, Matt Nash.

NASH: Bike lane designation needs to be reconsidered

On Wednesday I rode my bicycle across the Big Four Bridge, the converted railroad bridge that has been transformed into a pedestrian bridge and has been more popular than most people ever expected. As I was riding across I noticed that the markings that had been painted on to designate the bike lane have been removed. I was curious as to why and thought that I might investigate when I got home.

Tuesday, October 22, 2013

Here's one for Louis le Francais: "Paris Leads With Innovation in the Streets."


It now appears we need a little more Frenchness downtown; photo from the Louis le Francais Facebook page

Think of it as a corrective for those who insist that automotive rights come before quality of life. Livability in the whole city? What a concept.

Taking the Next Step: Paris Leads With Innovation in the Streets, by Stephane Kirkland (Project for Public Spaces)

In a 180-degree change from previous decades, during which public space was thought of mainly in terms of facilitating automobile circulation, the City of Paris has been implementing an ambitious strategy to rethink the role of the car in the city. The new approach, which puts the quality of the urban experience at the heart of urban policy, has led to a complete redefinition of Paris’s urban spaces ...

... The City administration feels that Paris’s current default speed limit of 50 kilometers per hour (31 mph) is simply not compatible with shared use of public spaces. So it has set its sights on a major milestone: the implementation of a 20 kilometer per hour (12 mph) speed limit within the entire city limits, except for a small number of designated major arteries. Already it has started an aggressive expansion of the existing 20 kilometer per hour zones.

The City has started implementing a new “shared space” concept. Several streets have been given this new status, in which vehicle traffic does not have the right of way and all users are expected to share the space equally.

Monday, January 30, 2012

Powerful stuff. But are "sharing" ideas too "political" for timid Main Street organizations?

There's a lot to chew on here; thanks Andy.

The blog is Strong Towns, and the article is Shared Space. The ideas for debating therein remind us that in so many ways, New Albany is sufficiently degraded at this point in time to conceivably serve as a bold laboratory of innovation, and yet we are held back from doing so not so much by short funds, but from the perpetual cautious urge on the part of community pillars to endlessly repeat their previous failed tactics.

Here's the intro:
The concept of building shared space within the public realm is a radical one here in the United States, where automobiles are not only given priority, but completely dominate most public spaces. With the financial insolvency inherent in our current approach becoming more and more apparent each day, there is a need to study alternatives. The shared space model -- while a dramatic departure from the status quo -- can help us build Strong Towns while making our urban neighborhoods safer in the process.