Showing posts with label Hama Rules. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hama Rules. Show all posts

Friday, April 07, 2017

Now more than ever: "US Military Should Get Out of the Middle East."

Hama Rules, 1982.

It isn't minimizing the horror of chemical weapons to offer a reminder that there is a thing called Assad-Vu in Syria: they've all been here before.

1982 Hama massacre

I've been around for 12 presidents (yes, a few months of Eisenhower, too), split between seven Republicans and five Democrats, and while they may seem to have little in common, most have seemed quite willing to bomb things. This might constitute something of a trend.

Journalist Phillip M. Bailey‏ won last night's local Internet with this:

Now we get to watch #Dems and #GOP switch their positions on #Syria airstrikes.

Yep.

US Military Should Get Out of the Middle East, by Jeffrey D. Sachs (Common Dreams)

It’s time to end US military engagements in the Middle East. Drones, special operations, CIA arms supplies, military advisers, aerial bombings — the whole nine yards. Over and done with. That might seem impossible in the face of ISIS, terrorism, Iranian ballistic missiles, and other US security interests, but a military withdrawal from the Middle East is by far the safest path for the United States and the region. That approach has instructive historical precedents.

America has been no different from other imperial powers in finding itself ensnared repeatedly in costly, bloody, and eventually futile overseas wars. From the Roman empire till today, the issue is not whether an imperial army can defeat a local one. It usually can, just as the United States did quickly in Afghanistan in 2001 and Iraq in 2003. The issue is whether it gains anything by doing so. Following such a “victory,” the imperial power faces unending heavy costs in terms of policing, political instability, guerrilla war, and terrorist blowback.

Terrorism is a frequent consequence of imperial wars and imperial rule. Local populations are unable to defeat the imperial powers, so they impose high costs through terror instead.

Thursday, April 06, 2017

Time to learn something: "Should America Have Entered World War I?"


On the 100th anniversary of America's entry into World War I, Donald Trump fired cruise missiles at Hafez al-Assad's son. Evidently there are Hama Rules, and there are Mar-a-Lago Rules, but since no one much bothers with history any longer, back to the legacy of the Great War.

It is the source of considerable chagrin in my interior world that an occurrence as cataclysmic as World War I is barely remembered. The topic fascinates me, and I've written about it often since the blog's inception. Here are the last ten or so major references:

An annual reminder: Forgotten fields in Flanders on Armistice (Veterans) Day.



"The nation must be taught to bear losses."



Roger’s Year in Music 2015 (Part 8): How did I die? A WWI lamentation.



Shells still explode in Belgium, one hundred years on.







Gavrilo Princip and the June 28 day.



WWI readings: From what was torn asunder to what was not rebuilt.


See this NAC search thread for more

I'll continue to make the argument that future historians will see World War I beginning with the first Balkan War in 1912, and in terms of cause and effect continued through the post-war settlement, depression and rise of fascist dictatorships, into World War II, then the Cold War, to the Yugoslav civil war in the 1990s. It will be renamed the 80 Year War, or some such.

An equally compelling subplot for Americans involves the way our entry into the war hastened the arrival of Prohibition. It's a case made by Lisa McGirr in her book The War on Alcohol: Prohibition and the Rise of the American State; mandated sobriety by reason of Protestant fundamentalism and anti-immigrant sentiment suddenly merged with sobriety as a patriotic imperative in wartime, and BOOM ... the foundations of greater government intrusion were quickly established and expanded in decades to come.

Michael Kazin covers numerous other key points in his op-ed piece. They're worth knowing.

Should America Have Entered World War I?, by Michael Kazin (New York Times)

One hundred years ago today, Congress voted to enter what was then the largest and bloodiest war in history. Four days earlier, President Woodrow Wilson had sought to unite a sharply divided populace with a stirring claim that the nation “is privileged to spend her blood and her might for the principles that gave her birth and happiness and the peace which she has treasured.” The war lasted only another year and a half, but in that time, an astounding 117,000 American soldiers were killed and 202,000 wounded.

Still, most Americans know little about why the United States fought in World War I, or why it mattered. The “Great War” that tore apart Europe and the Middle East and took the lives of over 17 million people worldwide lacks the high drama and moral gravity of the Civil War and World War II, in which the very survival of the nation seemed at stake.

World War I is less easy to explain. America intervened nearly three years after it began, and the “doughboys,” as our troops were called, engaged in serious combat for only a few months. More Americans in uniform died away from the battlefield — thousands from the Spanish flu — than with weapons in hand. After victory was achieved, Wilson’s audacious hope of making a peace that would advance democracy and national self-determination blew up in his face when the Senate refused to ratify the treaty he had signed at the Palace of Versailles.

But attention should be paid. America’s decision to join the Allies was a turning point in world history. It altered the fortunes of the war and the course of the 20th century — and not necessarily for the better. Its entry most likely foreclosed the possibility of a negotiated peace among belligerent powers that were exhausted from years mired in trench warfare ...