Esmonde's column is shared in its entirety, as he may as well have been sipping a craft beer at an outdoor table in our downtown when he wrote it.
Giving the people what they want on waterfront, by Donn Esmonde, BuffaloNews.com.
Of course, it’s working. It worked everywhere else. There’s no secret recipe or special formula. We have sun, sky and—most importantly— water. Just add a snack shack, put out some brightly colored Adirondack chairs, set up a kids’ space, mix in activities. All of a sudden, we have a down-town waterfront that people want to go to.
Just like a lot of people thought we would, once we got past our magic-bullet fixation. There’s no need to overthink it. To oversubsidize it. To overbuild it.
“It’s ironic,” said Mark Goldman, the activist/entrepreneur whose brainstorm last year changed the waterfront course. “The major economic-development success story in our community this year involves $3,000 worth of Adirondack chairs.”
Monday afternoon, more than 100 people walked or lounged at Erie Canal Harbor. A warm breeze ruffled a line of colored banners. Boats glided by on the Buffalo River. Folks lined up for sandwiches and ice cream at Clinton’s Dish—named for the governor who, at this site in 1825, opened the canal that transformed America. (Maybe someday we’ll get a sign that commemorates the fact.)
It has been nearly a year since Bass Pro, after years of arrested development, mercifully cut bait. It has been eight months since the landmark gathering at City Honors School, when Fred Kent of the Project for Public Spaces outlined a “lighter, quicker, cheaper” philosophy of waterfront development. The event, organized by Goldman, underlined what progressives had pleaded for years: Get over the heavy-subsidy, magic-bullet, lots-of-parking fixation. Instead, create a place where people want to go, and let human nature—and market forces— take over. Step-by-smaller-step.
Call this the Summer of Sensibility. The snack stand and mini-“beach” and Adirondack chairs and kids’ space and random activities—from yoga to Zumba classes—were spawned in focus groups and in public forums. The Erie Canal Harbor board, bereft of a plan after Bass Pro’s bailout, followed the people’s lead. Citizens committees—one includes Goldman, preservationist Tim Tielman and Buffalo Rising’s Newell Nussbaumer —guided the board’s hand. Finally, we’re getting the waterfront we deserve.
Lynn Skulski was sitting in an orange Adirondack chair Monday, watching the river flow. She left Buffalo for Florida eight years ago.
“I’m impressed,” said Skulski, who was in town visiting relatives. “Look at all the people walking around, on a weekday. Water is a big attraction. You don’t have to overcommercialize it.”
The Canal Harbor board’s plan, four years ago, was to build Bass Pro on this site. Instead of a public waterfront and Thursday night concert crowds, there nearly was a big-box retailer surrounded by parking ramps. Community blow-back, thankfully, killed the idea.
“You can build a store anywhere,” Skulski noted. “Why would you want to stick it by the water, and take up this space? It goes against the whole point of a waterfront.”
Amen. Granted, nobody is yet printing money at Erie Canal Harbor. But, at little cost and with a lot of imagination, we’re creating a downtown waterfront where people want to be. Where people go, commerce will follow.
“This is creating demand,” Goldman said, “instead of using massive subsidies to create supply, and hoping that the demand follows.
“It is not just people having picnics, it is good economic-development strategy,” Goldman added. “You start small, and it snowballs. By next summer, you’ll see private businesses lining up to come down—instead of asking for big, fat subsidies.”
Lighter, quicker, cheaper. Already, it’s working.
Fantastic article! Thanks for sharing this. I admit to a love of adirondack chairs myself.
ReplyDeleteWhat a great and apropos article for New Albany.
ReplyDeleteForces that be now and later here in New Albany,READ this,take to Heart. Garner the simplistic remedy.
ReplyDeleteGreat Article Thanks for sharing.
This is perfect.
ReplyDeleteIn the late 1960s, urbanist William Whyte studied public spaces in New York city using direct observation, publishing his findings in a book and a film, each titled The Social Life of Small Urban Spaces.
One of his main findings was that people liked and used chairs more frequently than immovable benches and fixed objects.
It is hopeful to see that someone understands the link between economic development and creating places that people love (as opposed to love to shop).
Cincinnati's riverfront park plan is also pretty amazing.
http://mysmaleriverfrontpark.org/take_a_tour.htm